All 5 episodes of the "Spider-Woman: Agent of S.W.O.R.D." motion comic are now up on Hulu for free, including the most recent episode that just dropped yesterday on iTunes for $1.99, which is a little puzzling, but who cares! Free stuff!Alex Maleev's art is incredibly gorgeous, as usual, but it's hard to get away from the fact that this a transitional work within a hybrid medium that doesn't quite know itself yet. The motion aspect works particularly well for establishing shots, as a ferris wheel spins slowly behind the neon sign of a hotel, the sun rises yellow on the water in Madripoor behind a gently undulating boat, and rain falls hard from a bird's eye view to the street below.
In comics, readers create the movement of images in the gutters between panels, but what feels strange in motion comics is the way part of that story -- the background -- gets set into motion, often beautifully, while the most central and emotionally significant images -- faces -- stay frozen in place. The dialogue works fine in the print version, of course, but if creators are going to design for motion comics then they really need to do that, and work around these types of weaknesses as they structure the art and story.
It's absolutely worth taking a look -- for free! -- if only to get a feel for the way the comics/video hybrid is evolving. The art is stunning and the talent top-flight, but personally I'd still be happier dropping $3.99 for the comic book version, since that's still where this story looks and feels the most at home.
Network: 






























Comments:
(4)Add a comment
Thursday 15 October
By Graham Simpson
Shame its not available here in the UK!
Reply
Thursday 15 October
By Laura Hudson
Aww, it's region blocked? That sucks.
Thursday 15 October
By Steven R. Stahl
The failure to fully animate the scenes is apparently going to be an intractable problem. Even dirt-cheap commercial animation has the characters' mouths move in sync, more or less, with their speech. The big question might be: How much would it cost to produce fully animated motion comics? Would people buy an episode priced at $6.99 or $7.99? Probably not. And producing a comic book with a motion comic in mind would produce an unreadable comic book -- the incentive to reduce dialogue would be too strong. But without narration or thought balloons --?!
Weeks ago, I suggested -- http://pwbeat.publishersweekly.com/blog/2009/09/17/did-val-discover-the-dw-griffith-of-motion-comics/#comment-3612759 -- that HEAVY METAL, which incorporated artists' styling of characters and backgrounds into the segments, would be a better model for realizing motion comics' goals. Currently, motion comics might have more in common with the old Star Trek fotonovels than they do with fully animated cartoons.
SRS
Reply
Thursday 15 October
By Steven R. Stahl
The failure to fully animate the scenes is apparently going to be an intractable problem. Even dirt-cheap commercial animation has the characters' mouths move in sync, more or less, with their speech. The big question might be: How much would it cost to produce fully animated motion comics? Would people buy an episode priced at $6.99 or $7.99? Probably not. And producing a comic book with a motion comic in mind would produce an unreadable comic book -- the incentive to reduce dialogue would be too strong. But without narration or thought balloons --?!
Weeks ago, I suggested that HEAVY METAL, which incorporated artists' styling of characters and backgrounds into the segments, would be a better model for realizing motion comics' goals. Currently, motion comics might have more in common with the old Star Trek fotonovels than they do with fully animated cartoons.
SRS
Reply