May 29th 2010 By: Caleb Goellner
A funny thing happened when David McLeish of parody/mashup site "
Square Root of Minus Garfield" (not to be confused with "
Garfield Minus Garfield" averaged the colors of every non-Sunday Jim Davis "Garfield" strip from 2007 - the compiled material revealed a pretty compelling...consistency.
McLeish's analysis of the blurred structure makes for a pretty fun read, even if his conclusions confirm what many readers from that year may have suspected. Along with a shared 3-panel structure and borderless middle panel, Jon typically stands on the left while Garfield stands on the right (almost like having a "side of the bed") and the dialogue rests on one common plane.
This straightforward composition doesn't necessarily detract from Davis' effectiveness. One need only look at Ryan North's "Dinosaur Comics" to affirm the possibilities even a literally unchanging layout affords.
Since this went live in 2008, it'd be interesting to see other a color-averaged compilation of earlier/later years. Stacked together, it'd probably look like something I could
wear as a shirt to a hippie jam fest.
[Via
Mezzacotta]
Comments:
(3)Add a comment
Sunday 30 May
By jakemanr12
Haha that's riiculous!
Reply
Monday 31 May
By HG
overanalyzing a tad, aren't we..McLeish?
I still think Garfield isn't bad even if in the real world when Jon would be another lonely man who talks to himself.
On that logic, Jim Davis was probably smoking hash when he wrote the original pitch for the comic.
The show isn't half bad. Mark Evanier was actually responsible for making the 80's show successful and continues to do a very good job on the current show that is airing on Cartoon Network. Though I use 90% fewer obituaries on Mark's blog site but you can blame God for killing those people.
Reply
Monday 31 May
By shutuprob
I find it hilarious that Caleb is crediting Jim Davis rather than "Jim Davis" as the author (as opposed to creator) of Garfield because it hasn't even been a secret that Davis has been using ghost writers/artists since fairly early in the strip's run, literally decades ago now.
-- Rob
Reply